Christian women lost baby in attack by her Muslim clients continues to fight for justice

Image

Islamabad: September 30, 2015. (Shamim Masih) After a violent attack on an expectant Christian mother who lost her child due to the severity of the attack, humanitarians and lawyers are calling for justice. The incident which occurred in November last year was based on the apparent untouchable status of Christians (Read more). The vicious attack involved Elishba being hit with metal poles while other men watched and jeered after an altercation with clients. The argument began after Elishba who provides beautician services asked for the fees for her service from a woman called Rani and her daughter-in-law, who Elishba had just completed work on. They refused to pay and Rani called her sons to attack Elishba who she said had insulted her and should not be able to speak to this way a Muslim. The sons then stripped Elishba naked and publicly humiliated her whilst beating her with metal poles. The BPCA visited soon after the incident and Elishba recalled the attack, she said: "I was deeply embarrassed at being being stripped naked so publicly the men had no thought of my honour". Elishba showed some of the scars on her legs from her brutal attack, these were not her worst injuries. Sadly she also described how the Muslim men beat her stomach when she told them that she was pregnant, the two assailants told her "Christian children are no better then faeces" as they murdered the embryo within her. (Read more) In addition to her child Elishba lost her phone, one weeks wages and gold jewellery which in total amounted to around £400 - these items were stolen by Rani's sons. Other Muslim men threw stones at her and laughed as she ran naked from the area. A Christian woman from the local area took her into her home, and covered her with some spare clothes. On November 19, 2014, Elishba Bibi, resident of Dagei, Jadeed Christian colony, Rana Town, submitted an application at the Police Station (PS) Ferozwala, Distt. Sheikhopura against Mubeen Gondal, Muneeb Gondal, Mahjabeen daughter of Mushtaq and Rani Bibi daughter of Mushtaq, stating that Rani Bibi, Mahjabeen, Muneeb Gondal and Mubeen Gondal had beaten her in the street, torn her clothes off and made her stand naked in the street. During the attack Elishba alleged that the group of assailants had beaten her badly and snatched Rs.10,000, a gold chain and her mobile. In her application to the police she explained that villagers in the street had seen the whole incident and that they had rescued her from a potentially more dire consequence. Elishba submited her application to register a First Investigation Report (FIR) against the attackers, however as per usual police insouciance, poor administration and deliberate malintent meant that FIR No. 1220/14 under section PPC 354 (assault and use of force on a woman with the intention of shaming her modesty) and PPC 379 (theft), favoured the culprits and the case was dismissed during initial local court proceedings. It transpires that the culprits had friendly relations with the local authorities, Police and even a PML-N parliamentarian. Knowing that their wealth and associations placed them in a place of strength the cheeky perpetrator of the attack on poor Elishba, Rani Bibi submitted a counter-application in Police Station Ferozwala against Elishba and six other persons, who had appeared as witnesses for her. Brave Elishba was not satisfied with the investigation made by the local police and fought against the counter-claim laid by Rana Bibi. A hurdle that few thought she would succeed with due to their obvious power and influence, and the weight of history in similar claims. Her defence council Malik Zaman Haider Gujjer argued that the police has maliciously ruined key facts and that their initial report favoured the culprits through maladministration and poor evidence collection. He successfully argued that the original FIR should have been registered under the section PPC 354-A (assault and use of force on a woman and stripping of her clothes with the intention of shaming her modesty and exposing her to public view); L2 337-F1(intentional harm to a person); 379 (Theft); 506 (criminal intimidation); 34 (criminal behaviour by a group, each member is jointly and equally culpable) and 452 (trespassing on a property with intention to kidnap, restrain, intimidate or assault) and after a successful hearing, her appeal for a review of the original investigation has been accepted. Lahore High court has now ordered the police to reinvestigate the case, accepting Elishba's petition. The BPCA has given one month's food provisions for Elishba and her family and next week Mehwish Bhatti will be visiting her to take her to a goldsmiths and replace her stolen jewellery. Our visit to Elishba was delayed due to her going into hiding after our original guide, the owner of a former Pakistani charity, failed to arrive at our meeting point on the scheduled date. Your BPCA team has been extremely embarrassed by this delay but we did not give up and are grateful for Shamim Masih, and his wonderful detective work, in making this encounter finally possible. Mehwish Bhatti has expressed great excitement at finally meeting with Elishba, she said: "When I first joined the BPCA Elishba was the first person I was sent to help, however acts transpired against us and it has taken ten months to finally meet my brave sister. Wilson and I have been praying hard for a breakthrough and God has made a way. I can't wait to take Elishba shopping! Her marriage gold was stolen, which will have hurt her confidence and pocket, but we will replace it to restore her sense of self esteem as it is important to her culturally. Moreover, I will assess how we can assist her and will make sure the BPCA gives her the help she so rightly deserves. When I think of the loss of her child I cry, but news of her legal breakthrough spurs me and the BPCA team on. Through God anything is possible." Naveed gives Elishba one month's food supplies.Elishba, a mother of 4 growing children, works as a beautician in various houses to make a living. Her children are all quite young aged 10, 8, 5 and 3 years. As a consequence of this incident, she lives in hiding and is struggling to finance her home. At the time of the attack she was 3 months pregnant and lost her expectant child which has left her scarred for life. Not a day passes when she does not feel that loss or remember the humiliation and terror of her ordeal. While meeting a BPCA representative in the office of her defence council, she started weeping and explained more of her difficult situation. She said: "Sadly my father and brother died in recent years, they used to support my children and I as my husband is unable to work. My wages are only a few thousand rupees per month so I cannot even afford to send my children to school now. I used to go to many more homes to work but after the attack I am too scared, I was dishonoured publicly and was expecting to die due to the threats that I would be burned alive. We were living a stable enough life before this attack now I find myself in despair." Elishba has made it clear that she desperately requires help with the school fees for her children which will be £30 per child. She has specifically asked for our help with this saying that she would really like to see her children educated properly so that they might prosper in life. She has also requested help with the cost of her defence counsel fee and other expenses which is around £400. Pakistani police normally do not investigate cases on merit alone and will only take action when outside pressure is applied. Since Christians are a deprived group who do not have the resources required to exert pressure on the authorities their voice often goes unheard. Unfortunately the courts are also influenced all too frequently by religious extremists and government institutions, making justice for Christians elusive. Wilson Chowdhry, BPCA Chairman, said: "Elishba Bibi has undergone a really traumatic experience and despite the pain she suffered, and the numerous witnesses who saw this, the Pakistani legal system has failed again in protecting its most vulnerable citizens. Unless legislative change brings about stronger more stringent processes to protect minorities, the ongoing hatred and pariah status of Christians will only get worse. Brave Elishba as a woman in Pakistan of Christian origin has shown us that through struggle things can be achieved. We at BPCA intend to support her as much as possible and I pray that people will respond to our appeal for this beleaguered woman."

You May Also Like

Image

HRFP-TFD Organized Event on Human Rights Documentation, Fact-Finding & Advocacy for the Marginalized-II

Faisalabad: Human Rights Focus Pakistan (HRFP), in partnership with the Taiwan Foundation for Democracy (TFD), has initiated a project’s acti

Image

President Asif Zardari urged to protect minorities in Pakistan. Report by Khalid Shahzad

Islamabad: Asif Ali Zardari has traditionally greeted Sikh pilgrims, Hindus and other minorities on the occasion of Christmas, Holi and now Baisakh

Image

PEMRA issues show-cause notice to Geo News for broadcasting Indian content following Asha Bhosle’s death

Islamabad: (PPF) On April 12, Geo News received a show-cause notice from the Pakistan Electronic Media Regulatory Authority (PEMRA) for broadcasts



"Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" By Nazir S Bhatti

On demand of our readers, I have decided to release E-Book version of "Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" on website of PCP which can also be viewed on website of Pakistan Christian Congress www.pakistanchristiancongress.org . You can read chapter wise by clicking tab on left handside of PDF format of E-Book.

nazirbhattipcc@aol.com , pakistanchristianpost@yahoo.com