Sheikhupura, Pakistan: An 18-year-old Christian woman, Muneeba Aslam, was allegedly raped and brutally assaulted while working as a domestic cleane
LEAD Ministries Rejects CLJ Report, Warns Against Introducing Caste-Based Divisions Among Pakistani Christians. Report by Sardar Mushtaq Gill
LAHORE, Pakistan: LEAD Ministries has strongly rejected the caste-based approach and recommendations presented in the recent report by the Center for Law and Justice (CLJ), titled Naming Caste in Pakistan, expressing serious concerns that introducing caste-based classifications into religious minority policies could create further divisions within Pakistan's Christian community.
Sardar Mushtaq Gill, Human Rights Defender and Lawyer, Founder and International Advocacy Director of LEAD Ministries, has criticised the proposal to recognise separate caste-based categories within religious minority communities, particularly the recommendation to reserve specific portions of existing minority quotas for Christians and other religious minorities based on ancestral caste backgrounds.
According to Gill, Christianity is founded on spiritual equality, brotherhood and the equal dignity of every human being. Christian identity should never be determined by ancestral caste, family background, traditional occupation or economic status. Within the Christian faith, every believer stands equal before God, and nobody should be treated as belonging to a superior or inferior social category.
He emphasised that caste-based discrimination originated within the historical social hierarchy of the Indian subcontinent and should not be revived, institutionalised or given a new identity within Christian communities through government policies, civil society initiatives or international advocacy programmes.
Christianity Does Not Recognise Caste-Based Superiority
Gill maintained that Christians, Muslims and Sikhs in the subcontinent have diverse historical backgrounds, including families whose ancestors belonged to communities historically subjected to caste-based exclusion. However, religious identity and human dignity must never be reduced to ancestral classifications.
“Christianity does not recognise any human being as superior or inferior because of their ancestry. We are all equal before God. Our Christian identity must never be divided into different categories based on the caste system. We should not introduce into our Christian community the very divisions that our faith calls us to overcome,” Gill stated.
LEAD Ministries believes that the Christian community must be recognised as one community of faith, where every believer enjoys equal dignity, respect and opportunities, regardless of economic circumstances, educational background or ancestral history.
Samson Salamat’s Warning About Elite Dominance in Civil Society Deserves Attention
Gill also referred to a thought-provoking Facebook post published by Samson Salamat, Chairman of Rawadari Tehrik, on October 30, in which he wrote: “Even within civil society, the elite seek to maintain their dominance.”
Gill considers this observation particularly relevant to the ongoing debate surrounding Christian representation, minority rights advocacy and the influence of privileged individuals within civil society.
He expressed concern that certain self-proclaimed elite figures within the Christian community may be attempting to establish their influence and social standing by promoting caste-based classifications and divisions among fellow Christians.
According to Gill, such an approach risks sidelining genuine grassroots leadership, ordinary Christian voices and middle-class representatives while allowing a privileged few to dominate discussions and claim authority to speak on behalf of the wider Christian community.
He questioned whether civil society should become a platform for elite control, personal influence and the creation of new social divisions instead of serving as a genuine space for equality, accountability and representation.
Gill emphasised that Samson Salamat's observation raises an important question: if civil society itself becomes dominated by privileged individuals, where will ordinary citizens, grassroots activists and independent middle-class leadership find meaningful representation?
He further maintained that no individual or organisation should claim a monopoly over Christian identity, minority representation or the right to determine how an entire community should be classified.
“Real civil society leadership should empower marginalised people, amplify the voices of ordinary citizens and challenge injustice. It should not manufacture new divisions, promote personal influence or establish social superiority at the expense of Christian unity. The voices of middle-class citizens, grassroots activists and ordinary Christians must not be sidelined by self-appointed elite representatives,” Gill emphasised.
Protect Workers Without Labelling Their Ancestry
LEAD Ministries acknowledges that sanitation workers, bonded labourers, brick-kiln workers and economically disadvantaged Christians deserve protection, equal employment opportunities, safe working conditions, education and access to justice.
However, Gill argued that these protections should be provided on the basis of economic vulnerability, occupational exploitation, forced labour and human rights violations rather than creating separate caste identities among Christians.
A Christian sanitation worker deserves the same respect, dignity and opportunities as a Christian lawyer, teacher, businessman or government officer. The nature of someone's employment must never become a reason for social exclusion or humiliation.
“Instead of dividing poor Christians through caste-based labels, we should fight the exploitation of workers, demand decent wages, ensure workplace safety, provide quality education and open opportunities for every Christian citizen. The real issues are injustice, poverty and discrimination. Our response should be empowerment and equal rights, not the creation of new divisions within our religious community,” Gill stated.
He added that protecting disadvantaged workers does not require dividing Christians into different ancestral categories. Government institutions should address poverty, unsafe employment, bonded labour and discriminatory recruitment through effective legislation and equal protection under the law.
An Appeal to Pakistan and the European Union
LEAD Ministries expressed concern over recommendations addressed to the Government of Pakistan and the European Union, stressing that policies concerning religious minorities must be developed through inclusive consultation and respect for the dignity, identity and freedom of affected communities.
Gill called upon Pakistani authorities, European institutions, international human rights organisations and humanitarian agencies to prioritise:
· Equal constitutional rights and employment opportunities for every Christian citizen.
· An end to discriminatory recruitment practices targeting religious minorities for sanitation work.
· Effective protection for sanitation workers and bonded labourers.
· Access to quality education, professional training and senior government positions.
· Economic empowerment of poor and vulnerable Christian families.
· Strong enforcement of labour laws and protection against forced labour.
· Equal opportunities based on genuine social and economic needs.
Meaningful consultation with grassroots Christian communities and independent civil society representatives.
Human rights policies that eliminate discrimination without institutionalising divisions based on ancestry.
Gill further stressed that international human rights advocacy should bring communities together rather than introduce classifications that could deepen divisions within already vulnerable religious minorities.
He urged the European Union and international humanitarian organisations to listen to diverse Christian voices rather than relying exclusively on a limited circle of influential organisations or individuals when developing policies affecting Pakistan’s Christian population.
Justice Must Unite, Not Divide
LEAD Ministries believes that the struggle for minority rights must remain rooted in equality, justice, freedom of religion and the protection of every individual from discrimination and exploitation.
Gill emphasised that poverty, occupational exploitation and unequal access to opportunities are serious human rights concerns. However, solutions must empower vulnerable people without making ancestral backgrounds the basis of their identity, dignity or social standing.
He urged Christian leaders, civil society organisations and international advocacy groups to listen to grassroots communities rather than allowing a small circle of influential individuals to determine the identity, priorities and representation of millions of ordinary Christians.
“Pakistan’s Christian community needs unity, equal opportunities, education, economic empowerment and protection of fundamental rights. We must not allow divisions based on ancestry, caste or social status to become a new source of discrimination. Nobody has the right to impose an identity or social classification upon another Christian. Our message is clear: protect the vulnerable, eliminate exploitation and uphold equal rights, but do not divide Christians in the name of protecting them,” Gill declared.
LEAD Ministries’ Position: Human Rights Without Division
LEAD Ministries maintains that genuine minority protection must strengthen the dignity and equality of every individual rather than create additional social categories or competing identities.
The organisation calls for policies that address poverty, discrimination, bonded labour and unsafe working conditions through practical reforms, equal opportunities and effective legal protections.
Gill concluded: “Christianity unites; caste divides. Our fight must be against discrimination, exploitation, poverty and injustice—not against one another. Protect the vulnerable, restore human dignity and uphold equal rights, but never institutionalise divisions in the name of minority protection. Christians are one in faith, equal in dignity and entitled to the same rights.”
LEAD Ministries – Defending Human Rights, Promoting Justice and Upholding Christian Unity
You May Also Like
SHENZHEN, CHINA: Sardar Mushtaq Gill, Human Rights Defender and Lawyer, and Founder and International Advocacy Director of LEAD Ministries, welcome
Italia: (Report by Adan Farhaj) Today, Monsignor Marco Malizia, Ecclesiastical Advisor to the Minister of Foreign Affairs Antonio Tajani, and Profe
On demand of our readers, I have decided to release E-Book version of "Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" on website of PCP which can also be viewed on website of Pakistan Christian Congress www.pakistanchristiancongress.org . You can read chapter wise by clicking tab on left handside of PDF format of E-Book.








